R G Kar verdict out today: Why Mamata Banerjee and TMC claim victory

West Bengal Chief Minister Mamata Banerjee turned the tide in the R G Kar Medical College and Hospital case through decisive actions. Protests erupted in August 2023 after a junior doctor’s suspected rape and murder. Accusations flew, alleging a nexus within the state medical system and political links to the Trinamool Congress (TMC). The West Bengal Police arrested Sanjay Roy within 36 hours, naming him the sole accused. However, protesters dismissed their findings, demanding a Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) probe.

On September 14, 2024, Banerjee made a surprise appearance at the protest site, catching junior doctors off-guard. Earlier, they had refused meetings with her and ignored her invites to her residence and Secretariat. Her visit shifted public perception. Protesters, once defiant, softened their stance four days later and agreed to meet her.

Banerjee conceded most of their demands, including the removal of Kolkata Police Commissioner Vineet Goyal and two top health officials.

Now, as the Sealdah court prepares its verdict, Banerjee and the TMC claim vindication. The CBI’s probe aligns with the state police’s findings, concluding that Roy acted alone. TMC leaders, emboldened by this, point to the government’s early actions. Party spokesperson Jay Prakash Majumder said, “The Kolkata Police acted swiftly and arrested the chief accused within 36 hours. The CBI findings prove our government was right.”

The victim’s parents, once critical of the state, now question the CBI. TMC insiders argue this shift highlights the politically motivated nature of the protests. They also credit their November 2023 bypoll victories, including a win in BJP-stronghold Madarihat, as proof of public support.

However, opposition parties remain critical. BJP leaders like Samik Bhattacharya argue the single accused’s hanging may not restore public confidence. CPI(M)’s Sujan Chakraborty criticized both the state police and CBI for failing to inspire trust, alleging a cover-up. Congress leader Subhankar Sarkar emphasized the need for the truth, asking, “Were others involved? Was there a conspiracy?”

Adding to the tension, another scandal hit Midnapore Medical College, where a woman died after childbirth due to faulty saline administration. Banerjee suspended 12 doctors, accusing them of negligence. Her tough stance aims to reaffirm accountability.

Meanwhile, Banerjee praised the judiciary and police for convicting a Hooghly district rapist in just 54 days. She posted on X, “No rapist has a place in our world. Together, we’ll make this world safer for children through strict laws and reforms.”

Saturday’s verdict in the R G Kar case could close one chapter while opening others. Banerjee’s proactive leadership has reshaped the narrative, but questions about justice and institutional trust remain.